Retirement account leakages probably reduce age 60 balances by 30%, but that’s not always bad news.
Researchers from the Treasury and Congress’ Joint Committee on Taxation have provided new estimates of how much money “leaks” out of 401s and IRAs based on restricted tax data. It’s a welcome addition to the literature because the existing range of estimates is enormous.
Leakages come from three sources: cash-outs when participants change jobs, hardship withdrawals, and the failure to repay loans. The government has attempted to discourage leakages by generally imposing a 10% penalty — in addition to regular income taxes — on withdrawals before age 59½. Employers are also required to withhold 20% of any distributions paid directly to recipients. Nevertheless, considerable money still leaks out. The question is how much.
Up to now, we have had three sets of estimates on leakages, from research conducted in the 2010-2015 period. The first is data from Vanguard, which suggest that approximately 1.2% of assets leak out each year. This number is probably an underestimate because Vanguard plans tend to be relatively larger with higher-paid employees, who have less need to withdraw their funds. The second set of estimates, which are based on data from household surveys, indicates that roughly 1.
For the record, I have always gravitated toward the conclusion that leakages reduce age 60 balances by 25%. But because the study indicating a 48% reduction is based on official tax data, it has garnered quite a following. The reason why the new study is so important is that it also uses restricted tax data. The new study, however, comes to a much different conclusion, suggesting that age-60 balances are reduced by 31% .
The authors of the new study offer three reasons for the difference between their results and the previous study based on tax data: 1) they defined leakages more narrowly, excluding distributions from defined-benefit plans and those on account of disability or death; 2) their contribution numbers came from third parties rather than household survey data; and 3) they netted within-year contributions and distributions. Those seem like good decisions to me.
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
How do I take distributions from his twice-inherited IRA?Making mistakes with IRA distributions can be very costly.
Read more »
18 Millennials Shared Their Debt Struggles So Gen-Z Can Learn From Them'I 'borrowed' pretty much all of the money in my 401(k)/IRA when I wasn’t working and had to have surgery. Big mistake.'
Read more »
New Moto G Stylus (2022) leak confirms the design and 90Hz screen of the upcoming mid-rangerThe mid-range Moto G Stylus (2022) smartphone with a 50MP primary rear-facing camera and 90Hz screen might be closer to an official release than previously believed.
Read more »
How do I take distributions from his twice-inherited IRA?Making mistakes with IRA distributions can be very costly.
Read more »
Key Reasons Why Bitcoin Just Tanked to $42K⚠ 6 Key Reasons Why Bitcoin Just Tanked to $42K $BTC bitcoin cryptocurrency
Read more »
Key Reasons Why Bitcoin Just Tanked to $42KThese are the top reasons why Bitcoin is under severe pressure right now
Read more »