+34
Excise duty cuts decision indicates if there is a strategic brain around the Cabinet table, it is being kept well hidden
Gardaí at Leinster House during the fuel protests in April. The reality is that the Government is running scared of the risk of further protests.
Photograph: Alan Betson’s economic opportunities have been transformed by the vast resources provided by multinational corporation tax, but its politics have been distorted by it. Political debate focuses on how much should be given away, with little thought of the costs. The price of yesterday’s extension – €407 million – or the €1.3 billion-plus spent on the cuts since March are afterthoughts.
The Coalition, blessed with a budget situation unique in Europe, is run on the basis of political expediency, rather that prioritisation. The risk here is of frittering money away and blowing a once-in-a-generation opportunity to invest in key infrastructure and genuine improvements in public services. When corporation tax finally tops out, or even falls a bit, what will Ireland have to show for it?
Karoline Leavitt leaves chaotic White House with immaculate timingThe Government’s decision to extend the excise duty cuts has been justified by senior ministers on a variety of grounds, one more convoluted than the next. , Taoiseach Micheál Martin said it was a temporary intervention and the extension of the cuts was designed to “manage the transition in a responsible and sustainable way at a time of great global economic uncertainty.
” Tánaiste Simon Harris said it was a “common-sense decision to keep the cost of petrol and diesel down and give households and businesses greater certainty”. The reality is that the Government is running scared of the risk of further fuel protests. And how can it offer certainty to households and businesses, unless Harris thinks he can head out to the Gulf and broker an opening of the Strait of Hormuz?
The Government has set a €2 a litre trap for itself. By setting this as a kind of Rubicon for petrol and diesel prices – despite the fact that current prices here are not out of line with Europe – the Coalition has set itself up for trouble in November, unless international wholesale oil prices start to ease back. They may do. But if not, will the excise cuts be extended again undermining the arithmetic underlying the 2027 budget?
It is a classic example of a Government getting through today with no plan for tomorrow. If there is a strategic brain around the Cabinet table, it is being kept well hidden. The Government is delaying the restoration of normal excise duties on one hand but hinting that it will look after us if prices stay high on the other.
In the Government statement on the delay, Harris said: “We will continue to keep developments in global energy markets under close review and remain ready to respond as circumstances evolve. ” This is surely a clear hint that further extensions are possible. Spotting the opportunity, Sinn Féin voted against the motion in the Dáil, saying there should be no restoration of higher excise duties with prices at current levels.
The party also wants the return of energy credits for all, which would be expensive and wasteful. Labour and the Social Democrats also support credits, though at least they propose restricting them to lower-income households. Dáil debates take place on the basis that the State’s budget will remain in strong surplus due to corporation tax. There is no consideration of the multiple risks caused by the AI bubble and geopolitical events.
Irish political debate exists in a world free of trade-offs – the need to spend less or tax more to pay for the costs of new policies. Warnings fromget precisely zero traction. Whatever the reality of departments trying to manage budgets, the public message is that the State is here to help. This is all based on a fallacy that the Government can step in and protect the public, no matter what happens.
Policy debate is driven by the image of hard-pressed households struggling to get by. And higher prices do indeed mean there are more of these. But there are also large numbers in the middle ground – feeling the pinch but getting by. And an increasing group of better-offs, benefiting from State grants to fit solar panels to recharge their expensive electric cars.
Policy measures – such as fuel cuts or universal energy credits- that treat all incomes alike are a dreadful waste of money. Many of the better-offs will not even have noticed the energy credits coming off their bills in recent years,on giving these to all households. And what happens next year when the forecast increase in food prices feeds through to consumers? Will the Government offer a backstop here, too?
Targeting can be difficult but is far from impossible. The same amount of money – or even less – can make a big difference to the households that need help, But will the Coalition – obsessed with helping middle earners – listen?
It is to consider other ways to support households and businesses on foot of a report due from There are big questions here – such as whether the world has moved to permanently higher and more volatile energy costs and if so how to support the less well-off. The Dáil debate also raised questions about the Government’s intentions on the carbon tax, due to increase each year until 2030, in part to incentivise the move to less polluting fuels.
And the budget is also likely to have new measures to help households to make energy upgrades with retrofitting, solar panels, EVS and so on – protecting them to an extent from price swings, as well as reducing emissions. Whether help for households in these areas, some income tax cuts and lower world energy prices allows the Government to deliver the promised phase out in excise cuts from November on is the big question.
But it will not be answered until after the Budget. This is because the Coalition wants to deliver income tax reductions for the middle classes on budget day. And if it had to count in the cost of extending the excise cuts further into next year, it would put a hole in the €1.5 billion available for its tax package. So the income tax cuts will happen.
And after that will come the decision about whether to go ahead with the planned phasing out of excise cuts, due to start in November. The tax figures in the October 6th budget will thus come with a health warning. The Coalition has caught itself in a trap, leaving itself reliant on events in the Middle East over which it has no control.
If there is a strategic brain around the Cabinet table, it is being kept well hiddenIrish Ministers are helping to reshape the EU as a defence alliance with a wartime economyMean Girls show cancelled mid-performance after power cut at Bord Gáis Energy TheatreGalway Races Ladies’ Day: ‘Colour and style just adds to everything that’s happening on the track’‘Your father’s playing golf in Doonbeg,’ Hennessy goes. ‘While the cat’s away, the mice will fornicate’
Government Simon-Harris Sinn-Fein Fuel-Protests Cost-Of-Living Strait-Of-Hormuz Fianna-Fail Fine-Gael
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Ministers to Approve Postponement of Excise Increases on FuelProposals would delay excise restoration until November with phased increases each month until February, avoiding pump prices exceeding €2 per litre for diesel and near that level for petrol.
Read more »
Special Dáil sitting to debate and vote on delayed fuel excise increasesThe Dáil will hold a special, one-hour sitting on Monday September 5th to debate and vote on updated legislation regarding the timing of fuel excise increases. The new bill postpones the initial increase from September 1st to November 1st, with further increases scheduled for December, January, and February. This adjustment aims to provide relief to motorists during the current high-price environment until market conditions stabilize.
Read more »
Dublin Lifestyle Trends: Sustainable Sips, K-Beauty, and Sporting LegendsAn exploration of the latest luxury trends in Dublin, featuring sustainable canned cocktails, advanced Korean skincare from Genosys, Caffé Nero's new matcha creations, and Katie Taylor's historic farewell event.
Read more »
Dáil vote on length of debate called before discussion begins over fuel excise duty cutsGovernment won vote on length of debate by 80 to 71 as Opposition says 60 minutes not enough time
Read more »