+34
Cashel Mulgrew won a case at the Workplace Relations Commission after his employer, Napier Couriers Ltd, docked his pay for accidentally damaging a customer garage door.
A courier whose pay was docked for accidentally damaging a customer’s garage door last year has won a claim at the WRC for non-payment of wages.
Photograph: Alan Betson/The Irish TimesA courier whose pay was docked for accidentally damaging a customer’s garage door last year has won a claim for non-payment of wages. The courier, Cashel Mulgrew, secured the decision at the Workplace Relations Commission under the Payment of Wages Act 1991 against Napier Couriers Ltd, which traded as Nügo and Fastway prior to going into receivership last year.
Mr Mulgrew spent about a year and a half at the company before quitting in September 2025 for family reasons, he told a hearing last month. The door was damaged during a delivery to a Co Mayo property in “severe” weather a few weeks before he resigned, Mr Mulgrew explained.
Top wealth management executive leaves Davy and it’s a good time to be an accountant Aoife Matthews, Jennifer O’Connell and Louise O’Riordan: ‘This is for our mothers, sisters, friends, and ourselves – so only the best will do’ “I went to open up a garage door at a property where we were delivering to and unfortunately in trying to push the garage door so it wouldn’t fall back down, the door came off its roller,” he said.
“I was able to still make delivery,” he said. “It was purely by accident, there was no intent to cause damage,” he said. A complaint to the company followed, the tribunal heard. Mr Mulgrew said a few weeks after that that, he decided the time was right to part ways with the firm and submitted his resignation.
“I got a phone call from one of the managers,” Mr Mulgrew said. “His exact words were: ‘They’re going to penalise you for whatever damage that’s been done on the garage door. ’”“I said also: ‘I’m employed by the company, so the complaint would be between the lady whose property was damaged and the business, not necessarily myself,’” Mr Mulgrew said.
Two days later, he received a payslip and found that €305 had been deducted from his pay for his second-to-last week on the job, he said. He said he understood that to be “half the cost the lady had claimed would be necessary to fix the door”, but that he was never shown any receipts or invoices to support this. He said when he complained about the deduction to the head of human resources at the firm.
The complainant said they later informed him a further €305 would be docked from his final pay, but that this didn’t happen. The cost of the damage to the door, he said, “should have been covered by the company under its insurance”. He added that if he was planning to stay in the job, he would have faced financial hardship and the possible loss of his tenancy on a flat he was renting in Sligo at the time.
The company management was not represented at the hearing, but was deemed by adjudicator Shay Henry to be on notice. He noted correspondence from the receiver confirming it would not attend. He accepted Mr Mulgrew’s uncontested evidence that the deduction was neither consented to nor provided for by contract. MOST READGirl taken to hospital after allegedly consuming cocaine at party, court hearsKatie Taylor’s career in pictures: The highs and lows of a life between the ropes
WRC Payment Of Wages Act Wage Dispute Courier Employment Rights
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
WRC orders clinic to pay 12,000 euros to GP and mother over demeaning conduct by receptionistA Workplace Relations Commission adjudicator has ruled that a receptionist at an Affidea diagnostics clinic subjected a Dublin GP and her elderly Pakistani mother to demeaning and disrespectful treatment, awarding 12,000 euros in compensation under the Employment Equality Act.
Read more »
Dublin Businessman Wins €75,000 For Unfair Dismissal After Objecting To Workplace WrongdoingPadraic Hanley, founder of PBR Restaurants Ltd which operates Dublin venues including Ouzos in Dalkey and Fish Shack cafes, has won €75,000 for unfair dismissal following a five-year legal battle. Hanley alleged he was forced out in 2020 after making protected disclosures about cash-in-hand payments, opening a cafe during an orange storm warning, and engaging an unregistered gas installer. The case centres on events after the company was placed in examinership in 2019 and taken over by new investors.
Read more »
Zverev wins wild five-setter, Rybakina and Gauff ease through at US OpenRain delays meant some matches were suspended while others were postponed.
Read more »
Sherry FitzGerald Wins 37th Irish Times-SCSI Tennis TournamentSherry FitzGerald emerged as the victors of the 37th annual Irish Times-SCSI tennis tournament at Donnybrook Lawn Tennis Club, overcoming competition from various property sector teams in a closely contested final.
Read more »