+34
The HSE Mid West is investigating a widely shared video that appears to show a healthcare worker speaking harshly to Ita Tobin, an elderly woman with dementia who was being treated for a suspected heart attack. Tobin's family has expressed shock and distress, while the HSE and Minister for Health Carroll MacNeill have promised that the concerns will be taken seriously as the facts are established.
The Health Service Executive Mid West has launched an investigation into a video that appears to show an inappropriate and distressing interaction between a healthcare worker and an elderly patient living with dementia.
The footage, which was shared on social media and has since attracted widespread attention, appears to have been recorded while the patient was receiving treatment at University Hospital Limerick for a suspected heart attack. The exact location, date and circumstances of the recording have not yet been independently verified, and the HSE said it is working to establish the full facts.
The patient was Ita Tobin, from Ballynanty in Limerick, who was living with dementia at the time of the alleged incident. Tobin later moved to a nursing home and died of natural causes on August 23rd last year. The video was reportedly sent to her daughter, Aisling Hogan, by a relative after it was posted online, shortly after the first anniversary of Tobin's death.
Hogan said she did not know who recorded the footage and described her reaction as one of shock and profound distress. In the recording, a healthcare worker appears to respond abruptly when Tobin asks whether she can have a cup of tea. The patient then asks what food is on the table in front of her hospital bed, and the worker appears to question why she is asking when she can see the items herself.
The exchange has prompted concerns about the treatment of vulnerable patients and the importance of maintaining dignity, patience and compassion when caring for people with dementia. Hogan said the footage was extremely upsetting and that her mother had been an intelligent and active woman who had contributed significantly to her community. She said dementia had already changed her mother's life and that the family felt as though they had lost aspects of her before her death.
Hogan condemned the interaction as degrading and inhumane, questioning how any patient could be treated in such a manner, particularly someone who was confused or vulnerable because of illness. The HSE said the behaviour shown in the video fell far short of the standards of dignity, respect and compassionate care that patients should be entitled to expect.
However, it stressed that the service involved and the precise circumstances had not yet been confirmed. The organisation said it takes concerns relating to patient care and safety seriously and that further work was under way to identify the healthcare setting, determine when the recording was made and establish who was involved.
Minister for Health Carroll MacNeill, through her private secretary, expressed sincere condolences to Tobin's family and acknowledged the distress caused by the circulation of the recording, particularly because it emerged around the anniversary of her death. MacNeill said responsibility for the delivery and management of health services rests with the HSE and noted that HSE Mid West was examining the matter.
She said it would not be appropriate to comment on the individual circumstances while the investigation remains open, but assured the family that concerns about patient care, dignity and respect are treated with the utmost seriousness. The case has renewed attention on the safeguards required for older people and patients with cognitive impairment in hospitals and other care settings. It also raises questions about how incidents involving vulnerable patients are reported, investigated and communicated to families.
Until the investigation is complete, the identity of the worker, the circumstances in which the footage was recorded and whether any formal complaint was made remain unclear. The HSE has not indicated how long the review will take, but the family is seeking answers about the care Tobin received and the events captured in the video
HSE Mid West University Hospital Limerick Dementia Care Patient Dignity Ita Tobin
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Decision due on HSE funding for treatment for rare genetic disorderThe drug omaveloxolone, branded as Skyclarys, was approved in the US for the treatment of the disease, followed by Europe
Read more »
HSE approves reimbursement for rare disease treatment SkyclarysThe HSE has approved the reimbursement for Skyclarys, a treatment for Friedreich's ataxia, making it available for Irish patients. The drug, which slows the progression of the disease, was previously rejected by the National Centre for Pharmacoeconomics and the HSE Drugs Group due to high costs. Communication between the HSE and the manufacturer led to a reconsideration and approval.
Read more »
HSE to provide Skyclarys drug to those suffering from Friedreich's ataxiaThe HSE has decided to provide the Skyclarys drug to those suffering from Friedreich's ataxia, a disease that causes progressive damage to the nervous system. The drug is the first treatment available which can slow the progress of the disease. The decision was reached after a substantial reduction in the asking price from drug company Biogen.
Read more »
HSE decision on Friederich’s ataxia welcome, but highlights ever-present conundrumAmid demand for best-in-class drugs, the State’s medicine bill is approaching €4bn annually
Read more »