+34
Kevin Sludds went from sleeping rough in Dublin to being a psychotherapist. He has lessons to share
Psychotherapist Kevin Sludds experienced homelessness in his teens, sleeping rough in the Phoenix Park and elsewhere. The experience has shaped his professional outlook. Photograph: Enda O'Dowd The human desire for knowledge runs deep.
It underpins our social order, our education system and the economy. But the paradox of knowledge is that getting more of the stuff doesn’t necessarily make us smarter. In fact, it can make us sick.series The Ascent of Man, where presenter Jacob Bronowski stands in Auschwitz, where several members of his family were killed, and declares: “We have to cure ourselves of the itch for absolute knowledge and power.
” Science itself has revealed that uncertainty is built into the universe, Bronowski observes. This draws him towards what he calls a “principle of tolerance... the realisation that all knowledge is limited”. Dogmatism dressed up as rationality is not only a source of moral decay. It also affects our mental health.
Kevin Sludds explores just how in a forthcoming book, Living Beyond Reason, that draws on his experience as both a psychotherapist and a lecturer in philosophy in Ireland and overseas. Sludds, from a north Dublin inner city family with Wexford roots, is not your typical academic. As a teenager he was homeless for a period of time, and the experience has shaped his professional outlook.
Evanne Ní Chuilinn: ‘Dad is at my brother’s grave most days and keeps the candle on it lit’Data centres in Ireland to be offered cut-price gas in return for possible supply disruption “What I carry with me is the cold – I remember feeling bitterly cold. ” But he also recalls an aspect of homelessness “that is never spoken about” – how it confronts people with “overt philosophical questions”.
“If you wake up after a night’s sleep on the Royal Canal or in Phoenix Park, as I did, you think of all the days and weeks ahead and ask: What is the point? What is this thing called life? ” People have a need for food and shelter, he says, but they also have a need for meaning in their lives. Sludds’s writing is admirably devoid of cliche, scathing of elites, and rich with put-downs.
Not everything should be reduced to “convenient collops of cognitive information”, he says. The “young and fabulously wealthy” Ludwig Wittgenstein comes in for particular criticism for trying to police the investigation of meaning under strict linguistic rules. The Austrian philosopher adopted a “religious attitude” in later life when he came to appreciate his early work was marked by “extreme dogmatism”, Sludds notes.
“Our search for meaning has now routinely become equated to what’s trending,” Sludds says, but that doesn’t mean our “everyday emoji ways of living” are ignorant or futile. A “traditional move” of intellectual elites is to “dismiss large cohorts of people because what they engage in is popular”, he says. Emojis aside, Sludds has a soft spot for what he calls an “anti-rationalist” stance.
He explains further as this week’s Unthinkable guest.
“To a very large extent, I would say. Taking the human condition to be one which is absolutely or essentially rational means, by extension, that to account for a sense of objectless fear, bafflement or depression, we must compartmentalise others and apply outrageously reductionist labels to them.
As a consequence, we not only have an ever-growing number of mental health disorders but of people who self-diagnose, and a simultaneous distancing from the reality that our lives very often do not conveniently conform to notions of reasonableness or order. ”“Fundamentally what we can take from Wittgenstein is an alertness to avoid arrogance and the inflated claims made for reason...
The propensity in clinical psychological and philosophical rationalist circles has been to eke out answers, missing the key point that there are few genuine insights in absolutes. ” Is there a danger of the anti-rationalist stance collapsing into self-delusion?
For example, I could take the anti-rationalist stance that a loving God is watching over me. That might be consoling amid life’s troubles, but I’d be kidding myself.
“The earnestness, or otherwise, with which we respect those who proclaim a belief in God stems, I would suggest, from the word ‘faith’, rather than from someone merely deciding to take an ‘anti-rationalist stance’. If faith is ignored and the belief is based solely on decision-making, an individual expecting an outcome of solace – ie ‘God watching over me’ – during life’s travails is likely to be disappointed.
An embrace of the uncertain and a step away from the delimiting idea of our being animal rationale is the best defence against life’s vagaries. ”“The key point here is that there is meaning in our apparent scattered or discordant emoji ways of living, our swimming in the shallow end of life’s coarsest distractions.
What the analytically rigid wish to dismiss is the ‘mob of men’, and elevate sages away from the hoi polloi so they can act as our guides. But what is actually required is the humility to stand out from ourselves and accept we live beyond reason and without definitive answers, recognising the world of difference which is present daily to us between our knowing and our living. ”That’s not a hum from your local data centre.
It’s a growing backlashSarah Moss’s last Irish Times column: ‘Being hated on the internet has begun to tint my life’Taoiseach ‘can’t see the capacity’ for return of energy credits in next month’s budgetHigh Court hearing to sanction Bawag takeover of PTSB set for October 27th
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Broadcast crews detail 12-hour days preparing Katie Taylor's final fight at Croke ParkKatie Taylor's final professional fight against Flora Pili at Croke Park brings major TV production from RTÉ, Matchroom and DAZN. Crews have worked 12-hour days, while RTÉ prepares free-to-air coverage of Taylor's farewell.
Read more »
Katie Taylor Poised for Historic Farewell as Croke Park Sells Out for Women's BoxingKatie Taylor will fight Flora Pili in front of more than 80,000 spectators at Croke Park in what promoters describe as the largest crowd ever assembled for an individual female athlete in any sport, with ticket demand surpassing projections and supporters travelling from across Ireland.
Read more »
Katie Taylor beats Flora Pili by unanimous decision in Croke Park farewellKatie Taylor ended her career with a unanimous decision victory over Flora Pili before more than 80,000 at Croke Park, retaining the undisputed super lightweight title.
Read more »
Katie Taylor's Farewell Fight at Croke Park: A Night of History and EmotionBoxing legend Katie Taylor made her final appearance in the ring for a sold-out crowd of 80,000 at Croke Park. The atmosphere was electric as fans from around the world gathered to witness this iconic event, singing along to traditional tunes and celebrating Taylor's incredible career. Despite the massive attendance, the fight was overshadowed by a technical issue with the ring's stability, leading to a temporary delay before the bout could proceed.
Read more »