+34
Northerners get cheered when they win Olympic medals for Ireland, but heaven forfend we might let them vote here
Fine Gael's Neale Richmond admits some party members 'are uninterested or uncomfortable' about even discussing a united Ireland. Photograph: Paulo Nunes dos Santosused to tell a tale about two newspaper headlines that encapsulated a British double standard about his national identity.
“Drunken Irish actor in brawl”, one headline sneered after a hell-raising night on the town by the Limerick native. “Talented British actor... ” bragged the other headline after he won an award. Ireland might laugh, but it can be just as hypocritical about who it regards as authentically Irish.
Ask this country’s citizens living north of the Border. Their tales may not be as amusing, but the identity bias they detect from the Republic is no less real. When Northerners bring home a haul of Irish medals from the Olympics they are hailed as national heroes, but heaven forfend we might let them vote for our president.is they simply must go on living with partition, indefinitely.
Their circumstances play second fiddle to the priority that unionists must be reassured about prospective unification. Four HSE regions to lose power over day-to-day spending Gaffe at Leonard’s Corner review: Super prices and a dribblingly good cheeseburger at this neighbourhood pub Northern unionists’ fears must be respected and allayed – but that should not mean airbrushing the wishes of northern nationalists out of the agenda.
The more it keeps happening, the more alienated from the Irish State they are likely to feel. Bunreacht na hÉireann has been averring since 1999 that it is “the firm will of the Irish nation, in harmony and friendship, to unite all the people who share the territory”. Therein lies the truth of the matter. Behind all the rhetoric runs a gamut of southern opinion from indifference to over-my-dead-body.
For the Republic’s armchair united Irelanders, making the island constitutionally whole again is as nice an idea as never having to die. Deep down, it’s comforting to know it’s not about to happen.
“They’re different up there,” some in the 26 counties say, implicitly blaming their fellow citizens for having evolved under different influences since the 1920 Government of Ireland Act carved up the island. During the Troubles, it was a source of frequent puzzlement how anyone stayed in the North. Nationalists could have packed up and crossed the Border to escape the stress of life in the place.
Violence on both sides was its extreme manifestation, but triumphalist parades and racist bonfires were routine provocations.this month – 28 years since repeated violent clashes put a stop to it – has tested its residents once again. The muted attention the order’s application has received in the Republic will only compound those residents’ sense of isolation.
Southern politicians – not confined to Fine Gael – know that, while the Constitution’s ambition rings with a sort of Celtic romanticism, when push comes to shove their constituents are not all that keen to welcome their compatriots back into the fold. Opinion polls have repeatedly exposed this ambivalence. One such was conducted for the North and South research project run by ARINS – an academic collective – and The Irish Times.
It showed that although more than two-thirds of respondents in the Republic backed unity, 41 per cent of those said they would be less likely to vote for it if it meant they would have less money in their pocket. This compares to 28 per cent of pro-unity Catholics in Northern Ireland saying less money would potentially put them off. Are citizens in the south prepared to change the national anthem or the flag to facilitate unification?
Not on your life.
“I’m all right, Jack,” the rescued sailor cried. “Pull the ladder up behind me. ” There was a time when the Republic envied the North’s comparative affluence – its motorways and efficient health service. Now the Republic is the richer of the two.
Yet the chant grows louder that it cannot afford the monetary cost of unification.report, Economic Overview of Ireland and Northern Ireland, showed the gap has continued to widen since 2018, when household disposable income in the south was 18.3 per cent higher than in the north. Hourly earnings were 36 per cent higher in the south in 2022 and the Government here now invests substantially more on healthcare provision.
Citizens in the Republic enjoy a two-year longer life expectancy than their counterparts in the North. It’s a poor republic that cannot give equal consideration to all its citizens. One that is willing to jettison some of its people to ensure a more comfortable life for the rest. The threat of civil unrest is cited as an obstacle to unification, raising the question if a State should renege on its constitutional aspiration for fear of reprisals.
The irony is thethreat of violent defiance more than a century ago contributed to ending the plan for home rule from Dublin and set the seeds for the partition that followed. There is a thing called loser’s consent, meaning those who vote against unification in a referendum are willing to accept the majority decision. If not, the new state would have a justice system to deal with violent subversives.
It’s easy to spout united Ireland platitudes when a majority in the North remains opposed to it, postponing any poll. There were sighs of relief throughout this island when British prime ministercould not vote for herself in the presidential election, there are more borders in our minds than we care to admit.
Northern nationalists are right to detect bias from their counterparts in the RepublicMOST READGerry Hutch’s son remanded in custody charged with serious organised crime offencesSaoirse Ronan walks red carpet in Venice for premiere of her directorial debutUnderstanding office politics: Personality clashes, power dynamics and unwritten workplace rules
Common-Ground Northern-Ireland Richard-Harris Republic Patrick-Kielty Ulster-Volunteer-Force Andy-Burnham Mary-Mcaleese Central-Bank-Of-Ireland Economic-Social-Research-Institute-Esri Orange-Order
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
I live in Northern Ireland and want to work in the Republic. How is remote working handled?Work Q&A: How does the Irish public sector typically handle remote working arrangements for Northern Ireland residents?
Read more »
David Sneyd Seamus Coleman Named in Provisional Republic of Ireland SquadVeteran defender David Sneyd Seamus Coleman has been selected for the Republic of Ireland's provisional squad for the Nations League campaign, with coach Heimir Hallgrímsson finalising the list next week. Despite uncertainty over his club future, Coleman insists a decision will be made soon and remains in contention as long as he stays contracted and trains regularly. The 38‑year‑old, formerly of Everton, could make a handful of appearances for Ireland over the season, having previously represented the nation on five occasions.
Read more »
Studying in the UK: ‘It forces you to step outside your comfort zone’From navigating the application process to adapting to new learning environments, students from the Republic share their experience of studying in Britain and Northern Ireland
Read more »
The Women's Podcast: A lawyer, a comedian, and a council estateRóisín Ingle speaks to solicitor and comedian Justine Megan, who is bringing her personal story to the stage in her Dublin Fringe show, "Exhibit A: Imposter." The discussion explores themes of class, identity, and ambition, along with other topics of the week such as the standoff between the GAA and Mary McAleese.
Read more »