+34
United fail to exploit advantage after Foden sees red in hotly contested Manchester derby
Manchester City's Erling Haaland celebrates at the final whistle after the Premier League match at Old Trafford, Manchester. Photograph: Peter Byrne/PAHaaland’s record at Old Trafford until this point had been one easy win and two defeats.
Now he was celebrating the sweetest thing in football – the hard-fought victory on a day when all had seemed lost. It had been another generally mediocre Premier League game in a post-World Cup season opening that has thus far been extremely underwhelming. As so often, the game was dominated by two bad refereeing decisions.
Not only did VAR do little to correct or mitigate the errors, it actually inserted a game-deciding mistake by reversing a correct offside decision that had been made by the assistant referee. Bezos-backed Liverpool look the most vulnerable ahead of new Premier League seasonZut Alors! - Ken Early in Boston, Gavin Cooney and Malachy Clerkin on the business end of the World Cup, At home with Malcolm The sensible decision would be to book both players and move on.
But Michael Oliver decided Phil Foden deserved a red card for kicking out at Bruno Fernandes, and VAR decided to overlook the awkward fact that this had been provoked by Fernandes kicking out twice at Foden, the second time while he lay on the ground. Fernandes helped make up Oliver’s mind by writhing on the ground as though Foden had actually hurt him.
Watching this ridiculous scene, Haaland would have recalled the fateful moment last April when he did not have the presence of mind to react in like fashion when he was lightly headbutted by Gabriel. Haaland was widely praised for his manliness and sporting spirit. Gabriel escaped a red card and a three-match suspension, and Arsenal went on to win the league.
The message was clear – TV refs can’t be counted on to spot injustice, but they will invariably reward theatrics. Intelligent players will act accordingly. Still, if City could have chosen a player to lose to a red card, it would have been Foden, who has hardly played a good game since winning both Footballer of the Year awards in 2024. The sending-off had a clarifying effect on Enzo Maresca’s team.
Enzo Fernandez had spent the first 20 minutes or so loitering in the space behind Haaland, leaving Elliot Anderson isolated in central midfield. Now he dropped deeper alongside his partner and became more involved in the play. More important than the tactical effect was the psychological one. City had been the victims of what they saw as an injustice.
Anger gave them strength.
“We knew we just had to run more and fight more,” Anderson reflected later. United, on the other hand, had been transformed in the same instant from underdogs to favourites. A home crowd that had begun the game in hope now watched in expectation. In the post-Ferguson era, expectation is United’s Kryptonite.
Rather than seize the day, Michael Carrick’s team wilted. Maresca made his first change at half-time, withdrawing Rayan Cherki for Iliman N’Diaye. This change was effective, with Ndiaye’s ability to dribble long distances and hold on to the ball under pressure buying City valuable seconds in possession. Carrick took until the 67th minute to make his first substitution and you had to wonder: what is he waiting for?
When the change finally came, it was Youri Tielemans who surprisingly made way for Benjamin Sesko. Maybe Carrick had concluded that Fernandes was dropping so deep – as though he was still playing deep central midfield in Ruben Amorim’s accursed 3-4-2-1 – that there was no point in Tielemans being there as well. It might have been better for United had Fernandes stayed further forward, in the areas where he could be more dangerous.
But Carrick seems to leave those decisions up to the players. United’s inability to come up with solutions will have been worrying for the United power brokers, commencing their second managerial “project” since Jim Ratcliffe assumed control of football affairs in 2024. In a way, the challenge of this game after Foden’s red was the task of United’s season in miniature.
An animated Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca and Manchester United boss Michael Carrick during the match at Old Trafford, which City won 0-1. Photograph: PA It’s one thing to take over a suffering team that is already out of contention for the big prizes and improve their form in the short term. We saw Ole Gunnar Solskjær do this at United in 2020. Kenny Dalglish did something similar at Liverpool in 2011.
The struggles both endured after that initial success showed that proving you can cope with serious expectation from the beginning and properly compete with the heavyweights is a different and much harder challenge. Carrick described the refereeing fiasco that ultimately decided the game as “staggering” – a choice of word that highlighted his inexperience. He’ll eventually get used to it if he sticks around long enough.
It was obvious to everybody that when the clearly offside Fernandez launched himself at Joško Gvardiol’s deflected cross and missed his attempted diving header by a couple of millimetres, he was attempting to play the ball. It was obvious that he was affecting United’s closest defender, Lisandro Martinez, who would otherwise have had an uncomplicated task to clear the ball before it reached the goalscorer, Haaland. All this was obvious to the linesman, who flagged for offside.
The offside was obvious to everybody, that is, except the video refs, who decided after multiple reviews that as Fernandez had not actually touched the ball despite launching every fibre of his being into the effort to do so, he was inactive and the goal should stand. A nonsense decision, but one Haaland might have felt he was due.
The first time he’d lost at this ground, it was partly thanks to a similar dubious offside call, when the clearly offside Marcus Rashford ran on to a through-ball but ultimately left it for Fernandes to sweep the equaliser past Ederson. Clearly, Rashford’s presence had affected City’s defenders, but the referees in their combined wisdom decided that, as he had not actually touched the ball, he was not affecting play. The VAR that day was yesterday’s referee, Michael Oliver.
Football fans are always asking for consistency, and Oliver at least is delivering.
‘As obvious as it gets’: Michael Carrick fumes at VAR call on Erling Haaland’s derby winnerMOST READLandlord who advertised house at higher rent after evicting family ordered to pay €15,000Removal of whiskey tariff ‘step in the right direction’ for hard-hit sectorIrish unity rather than protests the focus of US coverage of Trump visitLatest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers
Manchester-City Manchester-United
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Harris signals new Fine Gael focus on 'people who get up early'Tánaiste Simon Harris is shifting Fine Gael's political strategy to prioritize individuals who rise early and work hard, advocating for tax cuts and spending restraint over excessive public expenditure. This stance, reminiscent of Leo Varadkar's 2017 campaign, represents a significant direction change for the party.
Read more »
Haaland Goal Gives 10-Man Manchester City 1-0 Derby Win at UnitedErling Haaland scored on 60 minutes as Manchester City beat Manchester United 1-0 at Old Trafford despite Phil Foden's 22nd-minute red card.
Read more »
Enzo Fernández Plays Key Role In Chelsea's Win Despite Playing With 10 Men For Almost 70 MinutesEnzo Fernández was the standout performer in Chelsea's victory over Manchester United, providing a crucial assist and demonstrating excellent positioning as his team fought back after being reduced to 10 men. Despite the numerical disadvantage, Chelsea managed to secure a win against a struggling Manchester United side.
Read more »
Premier League Revises VAR Decision Over Erling Haaland's Controversial Manchester Derby GoalThe Premier League's Review Board has opened a probe into the VAR ruling that allowed Erling Haaland's 60th‑minute goal to stand after a post‑review that questioned the defender's off‑side position. Former United stars and analysts weigh in, raising concerns about the use of technology and the importance of on‑field review.
Read more »