+34
The BBC series This City Is Ours, now airing on RTÉ, has faced criticism for its reliance on stereotypical portrayals of Liverpool as a crime hub, underwhelming performances, and narrative confusion, drawing comparisons to shows like Love/Hate. The review highlights the miscasting of Saoirse-Monica Jackson as a gangster and the muddled character arcs, while questioning the show's ambition and thematic consistency.
Television: Biggest misstep is waste of Derry Girls actor Saoirse-Monica Jackson as a gangster Wag. Her performance is a scream into the voidThis City Is Ours is just another crime drama that paints Liverpool as a charming cauldron of crooks and cads.
Photograph: RTÉare separated by 140 miles, but on screen the connection feels much closer. Both are port cities historically looked upon with a degree of bafflement, if not hostility, by their fellow citizens – Naples is the third in this trilogy, and you can also chuck in Marseilles – and places that television has got a kick out of slothfully stereotyping as hotbeds of drug-dealing iniquity.and The Cage – dramas Channel 4 producer Jimmy Mulville has described as all having “a big bag of cocaine in them”.answer to Love/Hate.
Switch the accents and the shows are doppelgängers. As with Love/Hate , it is a tale of brutal yet lovable drug moguls, withheading the cast as the brooding family patriarch Ronnie Phelan and James Nelson-Joyce as his right-hand man Michael Kavanagh .
This City Is Ours, which aired on BBC last year and now comes to RTÉ, is, at one level, a visual love letter to Liverpool. The city is depicted as a heaving metropolis caught between the bustle of the modern world and the shadow of its colourful past .
TV guide: the best new shows to watch, starting tonightBut beyond this vaguely articulated sense that Liverpool is a special place that deserves to be championed, This City Is Ours doesn’t know what it wants to be. As Michael, Nelson-Joyce delivers a muddled portrayal of a thoughtful young man trying to outrun his criminal heritage and to start a new life with his girlfriend . Nelson-Joyce does his best to bring subtlety to the part of the conflicted thug.
However, his performance is entirely at variance with the cartoonish Bean. Theactor seems to think he’s rocked up in a straight-to-DVD Guy Ritchie rip-off. To that end, he goes completely over the top as the two-dimensional villain Ronnie. , left adrift with the two-dimensional part of a gangster Wag.
While she does her best to imbue her character with the vaguest outline of a personality, the script gives her nothing to work with. Her performance is a scream into the void. Jackson was hilarious in Derry Girls. She could bring the house down simply by adjusting the angle of a grimace or widening her eyes.
Alas that show remains the highlight of her career, and she has yet to find a new project equal to her talents. It certainly isn’t This City Is Ours – yet another crime drama that paints Liverpool as a charming cauldron of crooks and cads but lacks the wit or the will to do anything interesting with that cliche.
Three sporting events to watch this week: Your handy guide to sport on television‘Everything was bled out’: Publican says he can’t pay cleaner after losing nearly €200,000Clamping in Dublin city centre to largely be replaced by towing and finesElena Rybakina claims world No 1 spot in reaching US Open semi-finalsThe five main stumbling blocks on the road to Gaelic games integration
Crime Drama Stereotyping Miscasting Liverpool Critical Review
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Liverpool secure £300m, €350m front‑of‑shirt deal with Turkish Airlines for 2027-28Liverpool have agreed a five‑year front‑of‑shirt sponsorship with Turkish Airlines worth more than £60m a season, the club's most lucrative shirt deal in Premier League history. The partnership builds on Liverpool's record revenues and the club's historic international ties.
Read more »
Mac Allister: I could have left Liverpool this summerLiverpool midfielder Alexis Mac Allister has revealed that he was close to leaving the club during the recent transfer window due to his frustration at not being offered a new contract. While several of his teammates, including Dominik Szoboszlai and Ryan Gravenberch, secured contract extensions, Mac Allister was informed that the club was not in a position to renew his deal, which expires in two years. Despite this, he insists he will continue to give his best to Liverpool.
Read more »
This City Is Ours: The acclaimed British gangster series is finally coming to RTÉ PlayerThis City Is Ours, the acclaimed British gangster series, will finally be available to stream in Ireland this week. Coming to the RTÉ Player after airing on the BBC in the UK, the Liverpool-set show follows Michael (James Nelson-Joyce) and his sister Cassie (Samantha Robinson) as they navigate the criminal underworld after their parents are killed in a drive-by shooting. Nominated for Best Drama Series at this year's BAFTAs, the show has been compared to The Sopranos.
Read more »
Dublin City Council Phasing Out Clamping Vans in City CentreDublin City Council plans to reduce the use of clamping vans in the city centre as part of a new parking overhaul, replacing the current Q‑Park operator with Apoca which will rely more on towing, fines, and foot patrols. While clamping will still occur, it will be less frequent in the city centre and may increase in suburbs, aiming to improve driver compliance and reduce complaints.
Read more »