The judge said a “reasonably significant quantity” of images in the man's possession fell within 'category one' - the highest grade in terms of the gravity of such images
A man found in possession of over 300 images of child sexual abuse material has been jailed for 12 months. Eugene O’Sullivan, 62, of Dorset Street Upper, Dublin 1, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court to two counts of possession of child pornography at his home on November 19, 2018.
Imposing sentence on Monday, Judge Dara Hayes noted the creation of images of this nature involve the sexual abuse of children, which he described as an aggravating factor, along with the impact on these children and the seriousness of the offending. The judge said a “reasonably significant quantity” of images in O'Sullivan's possession fell within 'category one' - the highest grade in terms of the gravity of such images. He said the mitigation included O'Sullivan's guilty plea, that he has not come to recent negative Garda attention and his efforts to rehabilitate. The judge also noted O'Sullivan's mental health difficulties, personal circumstances and that he is assessed at low risk of re-offending. Judge Hayes noted Court of Appeal decisions state that the option of suspended custodial sentences must be considered in circumstances including where it is an accused person's first offence, that they have been co-operative, where there is no suggestion of the sharing of images and the offending is at a low level. The judge said he was of the view that a wholly suspended sentence was not appropriate in this case, as it was not at the lowest level of seriousness. He also noted general deterrence is also required in cases of this nature. Judge Hayes noted that while other similar cases before the courts could involve thousands of images, “it seems to me that 330 images is a significant quantity”, particularly as a portion of these images fell into 'category one'. He imposed an 18-month custodial sentence with the final six months suspended on strict conditions. At a previous hearing, Detective Garda Sean Harrington told Diana Stuart BL, prosecuting, that the Gardaí received confidential information regarding O’Sullivan, and a warrant was issued for his home. During the search of his home, a USB stick and a folder of printed images were recovered. The court heard that the USB stick contained 160 images of child sexual abuse material, while the folder contained 170 printed images. All of the images sampled by Gardaí from the USB were described as 'category one' images, showing sexual activity involving children. Within the folder of printed images, around 25 images were described as 'category one', with the balance categorised as 'category two'. He was cooperative towards the Gardaí and made some admission at the scene. The Gardaí were not in a position to arrest O’Sullivan until 2023. He made a voluntary statement to the Gardaí and was charged. Detective Garda Harrington agreed with Fiachra Treacy BL, defending, that 15 devices in total were seized and analysed, but only the USB and a folder contained images of child abuse material. He also agreed that O’Sullivan had not used a VPN to hide his activity. The Garda agreed with counsel that before O’Sullivan knew he was under investigation, he had deleted the images on the USB. Furthermore, the detective agreed that O’Sullivan sought help and showed shame and remorse for his actions. Detective Garda Harrington said he did not believe that O’Sullivan will come before the courts again. Judge Hayes asked the detective what ages the children in the images were, to which he replied, “between four to 10 years old”. The judge also asked if sexual activity with adults was involved in the images, to which the detective replied, “Yes”. Mr Tracey said his client had a difficult childhood and was subjected to emotional and physical abuse. He said his client has suffered from chronic anxiety for the past 14 years. Counsel said O’Sullivan was very remorseful and reports before the court placed him at a low risk of reoffending. He said his client has no history of drug or alcohol use. Mr Tracey said his client “is at a high risk of suicide, and prison would be very difficult for him” and asked the court to be as lenient as possible. Judge Hayes noted that the probation report expressed concerns that O'Sullivan appears to have a “deviant interest in children”, but other reports do not reach the same conclusion and O'Sullivan has denied this. The judge said O'Sullivan appears to lead a “reclusive” lifestyle. He noted his long work history, and that the defendant has not worked in recent years, his history of mental health difficulties and his recent engagement with counselling supports. The judge directed O'Sullivan to place himself under the supervision of the Probation Services for 12 months following his release from custody. Join the Irish Mirror’s breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive breaking news and the latest headlines direct to your phone. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don’t like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you’re curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Please follow us on Google to support usIreland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Concerns growing over future of BNY Mellon’s Wexford operationFacility employs 300 in town
Read more »
BYN Mellon announces closure of Wexford facilityMost of 300 employed in town will either have to relocate or be made redundant
Read more »
BNY Mellon announces closure of Wexford facilityMost of 300 employed in town will either have to relocate or be made redundant
Read more »
Stripe to Make 300 Staff RedundantStripe, the global payments platform, is planning to make 300 employees redundant in the coming months. The job cuts will affect roles across product, engineering, and operations teams in various locations. While the exact areas impacted remain unclear, Dublin is not expected to see a significant number of losses. Stripe, which currently employs around 8,500 people, anticipates its workforce to reach 10,000 by the end of the year.
Read more »
Ballymun to get biggest social housing development since towers demolitionAlmost 300 social homes to be built on land left over from Ballymun regeneration project
Read more »
Man found with 300 images of child abuse jailed for a yearEugene O’Sullivan (62) of Dorset Street Upper, Dublin 1, pleaded guilty at Dublin Circuit Criminal Court
Read more »