Brazilian Renato Gehlen, who denies murder, is appealing life sentence handed down in 2021
Gehlen claimed that Ms Colomines had stabbed herself four times during a struggle, which included a fatal injury that penetrated her heart and a 22cm-long knife wound across her neck.
The prosecution had described Gehlen’s account that Ms Colomines had stabbed herself to death after they fought about “another man” as “ridiculous” and “insulting” to the jury. Mr Clarke said the row between Gehlen and Ms Colomines lasted 11 minutes and that this could be “an insufficient amount of time for provocation to dissipate”, which did not bar this line of defence possibly being put to a jury.
Mr Clarke said Gehlen had claimed that Ms Colomines asked for space, then produced a knife and cut herself, telling him: “If you want to damage me or destroy me I am going to destroy you even worse.” Presiding judge Mr Justice George Birmingham said that there was no evidence of any loss of control by Mr Gehlen and that therefore any jury would have had to “dream up a defence” itself in relation to provocation.
Shane Costelloe SC, for the State, said Gehlen had denied stabbing his wife and added that it was “frankly, entirely contradictory that this was an accident, or an accident and self-harm” for the defence to now say there was an element of provocation.
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Ex-Met Police officer and convicted murderer Wayne Couzens admits three counts of indecent exposureWayne Couzens has admitted three counts of indecent exposure before he abducted, raped and murdered Sarah Everard
Read more »
Caged killer Michael Leonard moved to Cork hospital eight weeks into life termMurderer Leonard is bedridden just eight weeks into life sentence for setting fire to a woman he had become obsessed with
Read more »
Russian forces claim gains along Ukraine frontlineRussia said its troops had pushed forward a few kilometres along the frontlines in Ukraine, while Kyiv said its forces had repelled Russian attacks in several areas.
Read more »
Omagh CBS claim MacRory Cup final gloryHoly Trinity Cookstown fail to build on a positive start to only the second all-Tyrone decider in the competition
Read more »
Cork school syndicate claim EuroMillions Plus prize worth €500,000A holiday to Bali, a six-month supply of takeaways, tickets to a Beyoncé concert in London and a Bruce Springsteen concert in Paris are just some of the ways they plan to splash their cash
Read more »
Woman (25) settles action alleging birth injuries for record €35.2 millionHSE denied claim and contended management of birth complied with general and approved practice
Read more »