+34
The row over Skyclarys, a new drug for Friedreich’s ataxia patients, was the political story of the week
Drug-approval process is too long and multilayered to survive a guerrilla attack from politicians in an age of social media. File image. Photograph: Gettyf sucking diesel were a cure for Friedreich’s ataxia then Leinster House would be Lourdes.
The Dáil meets in special session on Friday to roll over subsidies on fossil fuels that have already cost an additional €1 billion this year. The political story this week, though, has been thewas €280,000 per patient per year or a likely €130 million over five years if all eligible patients were treated. It wasn’t remotely cost-effective at that price, but the political bandwagon didn’t care. After all, it is somebody else’s money.
Irish man arrested over alleged anti-Semitic death threat to couple in French supermarketScramble to find new wedding venues as luxury hotel closes after norovirus outbreakfrom €499 million to €187 million. That is a reduction of €312 million or 62.5 per cent. Even in a country where billions of euro are squandered and the health budget is overrunning, €312 million is a lot of money if you care about patients’ health.
I admire how Friedreich’s ataxia patients and their families fought their corner. A rare disease that afflicts about 200 people in Ireland, it is not only debilitating and shortens life expectancy, but is a condition for which no other approved treatment is available. Skyclarys, for over-16s, has the ability to slow the progression of the condition. This is welcome.
Biogen, the manufacturer, sought to get the best reward for the risk of developing a new drug for a very small cohort. But, however imperfectly, it is the unloved HSE that represents the public interest. It was unforgivable that the public interest was being gratuitously shafted for the sake of political opportunism at the expense of patients generally, including those with Friedreich’s ataxia. What is clear is that the drug-approval process is vulnerable politically.
It is too long and multilayered to survive a guerrilla attack from politicians in an age of social media. Their dividend is the publicity itself. The ultimate outcome is secondary and the financial cost is irrelevant. There is an obligation in law to make decisions within 180 days on applications for reimbursement of drugs.
That seldom happens and didn’t in this case. If the fault is foot-dragging pharma companies then there is a clear case for dismissal of the claim for reimbursement. If the public interest is to be defended effectively then the process must be shorter and more focused. Making decisions on reimbursing drugs in the court of public opinion condemns patients to Animal Farm where “all animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others”.
It is nasty and incompetent politics. In the meantime the drug was approved this week for an unknown but lesser price. If this public showdown is a new normal, and it’s not unprecedented, it means things must change to stop decisions on medicines being made by force of public opinion. What is unprecedented is fragmenting politics and a nearly unanimous belief that there is a bottomless pit of public money.
I use the word unanimous deliberately because I struggle to think of a single party or even one TD who will oppose in principle the continuation of fuel subsidies today. Ireland is now a country where there is in effect a cap on fuel prices because, as determined protesters found out last Easter week, the Government won’t allow prices rise above its own very low pain threshold.
When they lost control of O’Connell Street on the days after Easter, they lost their nerve and lost control of the country. The premise of this Government in its new iteration of January 2025 was that budgeting on the hoof was over and that its figures would be facts. It was a promise that was abandoned immediately – and public spending bears no relation to what is planned.made great play over the summer, probably sincerely, of holding the line.
But the events of this week wash that line away. In the noughties we flattered ourselves that our economic choice was between Boston and Berlin. The decline in political capacity is so palpable it seems our choice today is between Lisdoonvarna and Las Vegas. On the essential function of the State, on how toand spend, there is virtual political unanimity: nobody is prepared to propose a significant realignment of the tax base and nobody will propose limiting spending.
The proposal that there should be early access to all drugs for rare diseases is pie in the sky unless we tax to pay for it. In the circumstances, nobody should be surprised by the stupidity or the cruelty of inflating the cost of expensive medicines. As politics proliferates, real difference has evaporated. Few one-party states are as united ideologically as the Dáil that meets on Friday.
But competition is fierce, and therefore finding differences on something is essential. Friday’s session will end in disagreement not on any essential but on spurious differences. Vast sums will be squandered ineffectively. It might be a clue as to the priority really given to rare diseases.
But it is certainly a guide on how to bandwagon on them. Irishman’s 1860s speeches on Canada’s right to self-determination could have been written last weekIrish woman named as Spanish police await postmortems on couple found dead in hot tubIrish citizens missing in Nepal appear on list of unaccounted for tourists after flash floodWho is the Swiss politician accused of drugging and sexually abusing an Irish girl and her mother?
Cost of college: How much can you expect to pay for third-level education in Ireland?
Biogen Hse Jack-Chambers Tax Fuel-Protests Dail-Eireann
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Tragic Fire at Pakistan Hospital Claims Lives of 14 NewbornsA devastating fire in the maternity ward of Pakistan Institute of Medical Sciences has resulted in the death of 14 newborn babies. The blaze, which occurred early Wednesday, engulfed the ward while the infants were under care. Investigation is ongoing to determine the cause of the fire.
Read more »
Troy Parrott's La Liga Debut: A Missed Opportunity or a Promising Start?Troy Parrott made his La Liga debut for Real Betis in a tense 0-0 draw against Valencia, coming off the bench in the 63rd minute. While he narrowly missed a golden scoring opportunity early in his appearance, his overall play showed promise and could signal a successful adaptation to the Spanish league.
Read more »
RTÉ Reports Low Take‑Up of Early Exit Package, Affecting Future Redundancy PlansRTÉ's internal analysis shows a limited uptake of its voluntary exit programme, with only about 40 offers made to 134 applicants and a 60% acceptance rate, prompting concerns about the feasibility of similar schemes in the future and the cost implications for the broadcaster.
Read more »
Elderly couple critically injured after car crashes off M50 bridge near BallymountA man and woman in their 80s were left with serious injuries after their car crashed off a bridge near the M50 in Dublin. The incident occurred as they were leaving the motorway at Junction 10, near the Ballymount slip road, causing heavy traffic congestion. The crash is being investigated by authorities, with early images showing a broken barrier at the bridge's edge.
Read more »