Opinion | The Jan. 6 committee's very bad immunity idea

Ireland News News

Opinion | The Jan. 6 committee's very bad immunity idea
Ireland Latest News,Ireland Headlines
  • 📰 MSNBC
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 72 sec. here
  • 3 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 32%
  • Publisher: 51%

Jeffrey Clark is a relatively big fish in the ocean of people already called before the Jan. 6 select committee. And it would be a huge mistake to offer him any kind of immunity.

,” which allows prosecutors to still charge a defendant as long as they don’t use anything they learned from the immunized defendant’s testimony, sounds great in a law school classroom, but not in a courtroom. If select committee members think they can get Clark to cough up his cohorts — maybe even a former president – and still expect DOJ to charge Clark, then they should check out the case law.

In the infamous Iran-Contra arms for hostages case against Lt. Col. Oliver North, who served in the Reagan administration, a federal judge after special prosecutor Lawrence Walsh conceded he couldn’t prove that North’s convictions weren’t influenced by North’s immunized congressional testimony. Walsh blamed Congress.More recently, and in the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, a judge dismissed charges against members of the private security firm Blackwater because prosecutorsby testimony provided by immunized defendants.

Third, and perhaps most importantly, Lofgren’s public pondering of immunity for Clark raises serious concerns about the current state of communication between the committee and DOJ, and DOJ’s willingness to hold higher-ups accountable. Whilein return for testimony, any prosecutive decisions are made by the DOJ. It’s DOJ that would have to live with the undesirable results of Congress granting immunity to Clark.

There is one potential ray of light in this otherwise gloomy forecast. It’s possible that the committee and DOJ are somehow convinced that Clark holds the key to directly implicating Trump and they believe he’s willing to turn that key. It’s a long-shot bet that isn’t worth the risk of effectively jeopardizing holding Clark accountable. If Clark holds the Trump key, then he’s much more likely to use it if he’s staring at a criminal indictment instead of immunity.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

MSNBC /  🏆 469. in US

Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Rubio: Jan. 6 committee a 'complete partisan scam'Rubio: Jan. 6 committee a 'complete partisan scam'Rubio's comments are in line with the Republican National Committee, which this week voted to censure GOP Reps. Liz Cheney and Adam Kinzinger.
Read more »

Chris Christie rips Trump's Jan. 6 claims: 'He actually told the truth by accident'Chris Christie rips Trump's Jan. 6 claims: 'He actually told the truth by accident'Former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie did not hold back Sunday in his criticism of how former President Donald Trump has sought to depict the deadly Jan. 6 attack against the Capitol.
Read more »

Investigators interested in Ivanka Trump’s recollections of father’s actions on Jan. 6Investigators interested in Ivanka Trump’s recollections of father’s actions on Jan. 6The House committee investigating the Jan. 6 riot wants to know what Ivanka Trump heard and saw that day.
Read more »

Trump's Offer Of Jan. 6 Pardons Sure 'Sounds Like' Obstruction Of Justice, Says John DeanTrump's Offer Of Jan. 6 Pardons Sure 'Sounds Like' Obstruction Of Justice, Says John Dean“If the Justice Department isn’t tracking this stuff, I don’t know what our Justice Department is for,” Dean told Jim Acosta.
Read more »

Top GOP lawmaker won't condemn calling events of Jan. 6 'legitimate political discourse'Top GOP lawmaker won't condemn calling events of Jan. 6 'legitimate political discourse'
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-29 14:35:10