Opinion | Yes, Windfall Taxes on Big Oil Are Warranted—But That's Not All

Ireland News News

Opinion | Yes, Windfall Taxes on Big Oil Are Warranted—But That's Not All
Ireland Latest News,Ireland Headlines
  • 📰 commondreams
  • ⏱ Reading Time:
  • 40 sec. here
  • 2 min. at publisher
  • 📊 Quality Score:
  • News: 19%
  • Publisher: 51%

'While windfall taxes are undoubtedly justified, their efficacy is suspect.'

Windfall taxes are utterly defensible as levies on unexpected pure rents that recipients did nothing to deserve and that they receive only by virtue of enjoying a position of market power within an economy. The usual criticisms of taxation as market-distorting, price-signal-jamming, investment-deterring state intervention do not hold.

But while windfall taxes are undoubtedly justified, their efficacy is suspect. We know that electricity companies belong to multinational corporations skilled in the dark arts of obscuring their profits through complex intra-organizational trades. We also know that, unwilling to be content with profits from electricity, they indulge themselves in derivative trades that can wipe out—or seem to wipe out—much of their windfall profits during times like this.

For these reasons, windfall taxes are necessary but insufficient. Governments should aim to prevent the windfall profits from reaching these companies in the first place, by imposing wholesale price caps on non-gas-using electricity producers, which reflect their average cost plus a reasonable net return.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

commondreams /  🏆 530. in US

Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines

Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

13 Parsnip Recipes for That Sweet Fall Flavor13 Parsnip Recipes for That Sweet Fall FlavorYes, you can roast them. But that's not all.
Read more »

Manchin 'Getting Desperate' as Opposition to Dirty Permitting Deal Grows LouderManchin 'Getting Desperate' as Opposition to Dirty Permitting Deal Grows LouderAfter the West Virginia senator claimed he's a victim of 'revenge politics,' Sen. Bernie Sanders responded: 'Defeating the Big Oil side deal is not about revenge.'
Read more »

Pete Davidson Hits 'Meet Cute' Premiere with Kaley Cuoco, Kim K in NYC TooPete Davidson Hits 'Meet Cute' Premiere with Kaley Cuoco, Kim K in NYC TooPete Davidson's back in the Big Apple with a new woman on his arm -- yes, she's his costar, Kaley Cuoco -- but interestingly enough, his ex, Kim Kardashian, was also in town.
Read more »

Alaskans pocket over $3,000 in annual oil-wealth paymentsAlaskans pocket over $3,000 in annual oil-wealth paymentsNearly every single Alaskan got a financial windfall amounting to more than $3,000 Tuesday.
Read more »

Alaskans pocket over $3,000 in annual oil-wealth paymentsAlaskans pocket over $3,000 in annual oil-wealth paymentsNearly every single Alaskan got a financial windfall amounting to more than $3,000 Tuesday
Read more »

Reba McEntire gets to show off her dark side in season 3 of ABC thriller 'Big Sky: Deadly Trails'Reba McEntire gets to show off her dark side in season 3 of ABC thriller 'Big Sky: Deadly Trails'We know country music legend Reba McEntire as someone full of sweetness and light, but that's about to change with season three of the ABC series 'Big Sky: Deadly Trails.'
Read more »



Render Time: 2025-03-05 04:36:22