+34
Ombudsman finds police investigation into allegations against Jonathan Creswell was ‘inadequate’
4 MIN READ A PSNI investigation into an alleged act of indecent exposure by the man who was charged with the murder of Katie Simpson was “inadequate”, the Northern Ireland’s Police Ombudsman has found.
The ombudsman revealed the complainant was failed after officers took no additional statements despite there being three potential witnesses, and did not listen to an allegedly threatening voice message sent to the victim. Simpson, from Tynan, Co Armagh, died in Altnagelvin Area Hospital almost a week after an incident in Gortnessy Meadows, Lettershandoney.
Clamping in Dublin city centre to be largely replaced by towing and finesIt was not until the following year that Jonathan Creswell, the partner of Simpson’s sister, was arrested on suspicion of murder. The trial of Creswell , for the murder of Simpson ended in April 2024 after he took his own life following the first day of proceedings.
After Creswell’s death a woman made a complaint to the Police Ombudsman raising concerns on how police had dealt with a report she made in January 2016, that he exposed himself to her at a horse yard in Co Antrim some months prior. The ombudsman found a number of shortcomings in the police investigation, such as the officer that was initially assigned to the case recording only one witness statement during the four months she was in charge.
A second officer subsequently allocated the case did not obtain any further statements, and neither officer listened to a recording of an allegedly threatening voice message sent by Creswell. Furthermore, the ombudsman found the file submitted to the Public Prosecution Service by the second investigating officer was inaccurate.
It stated that Creswell was known to police only for motoring offences, when he had previously been jailed for violent offending against a woman; and incorrectly stated that there was no outstanding evidence and no other witnesses in the case. Katie Simpson, from Tynan, Co Armagh, died in Altnagelvin Area Hospital almost a week after an incident in Gortnessy Meadows, Lettershandoney.
Photograph: Simpson family The PPS subsequently directed that there was insufficient evidence to prosecute but advised that if Creswell was interviewed about the allegation in future, the file could be resubmitted for further consideration. When interviewed by Police Ombudsman investigators, the police officer initially assigned to the case said she would have obtained the outstanding witness statements if she had kept ownership of the investigation.
The second officer, who was allocated the case five months after the initial allegation, said he had not been instructed to obtain any further evidence and believed his role to have been in a monitoring capacity. He added that he had not considered Creswell’s previous violent offending to be relevant to the case. The Police Ombudsman’s Director of Investigations, Nikki Davis, said police “failed the complainant, both as a woman and as a victim”.
“Indecent exposure is a serious crime and can indicate a potential for escalating sexual offending, so it is important that reports are robustly investigated,” she said. “We also know that sexual crime is underreported, and that it takes great courage for victims to go to the police.
“Unless reports of sexual offences are properly investigated, victims will be less likely to come forward, offenders will remain free to reoffend, and efforts to combat violence and sexual offending against women and girls will be undermined. ” She added: “Indecent exposure is a non-contact sexual offence and a form of sexual violence, so the prior conviction was entirely relevant and should have been disclosed to the PPS.
“It is widely acknowledged that police should be looking at behavioural patterns across incidents and seeking to identify where repeat offending might indicate escalating risk. The Police Ombudsman also found that the officers had made inadequate inquiries to locate and interview Creswell. Davis did note that the officers had attempted to contact Creswell by phone, visited an address associated with him, made inquiries relating to his equestrian background and placed alerts on police systems about two vehicles linked to him.
In a misconduct file submitted to the PSNI, the Police Ombudsman recommended that the two officers should be disciplined for failing to properly investigate the case and not providing adequate updates to the complainant. After considering the file, the PSNI determined that the issues identified would be better addressed by taking measures intended to improve the officers’ conduct.
Police Ombudsman investigators were unable to complete their inquiries into a separate allegation involving a different police officer who retired during the course of the investigation. The complainant believed the officer was trying to stop her from talking to the media. Before retiring the officer provided a statement that he had called her to advise of the intended police response to a media query, and about how information about the case could be reported and used.
Although the complaint to the Police Ombudsman’s Office was initially closed, a fresh investigation was commenced upon receipt of further correspondence from the complainant. – PALaw Society asks Minister to consider mediator in bid to end legal aid fees rowClamping in Dublin city centre to be largely replaced by towing and finesIceland summons US ambassador after Trump posts map showing island under American flag‘People just want safety’: Migrants feel ‘targeted’ by Irish citizenship reforms
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Katie Taylor's Croke Park Fight Draws Peak Audience of 1.6 Million on RTÉKatie Taylor's unanimous points victory over Flora Pili at Croke Park attracted a peak RTÉ television audience of 1.6 million viewers and an average of 973,000, with an additional 552,000 streams on the RTÉ Player. The event, held before 80,000 fans, marked the first boxing match at Croke Park since Muhammad Ali's 1972 fight. Taylor retained her WBA, IBF, and WBO super-lightweight titles and claimed the vacant IBO and WBC belts. RTÉ director of video Steve Carson called it a national moment. DAZN served as the global broadcaster, partnering with RTÉ for Irish coverage. The viewership exceeded the peak audience for the 2026 World Cup final.
Read more »
Dispute over failed Irish Rail IT project could end up in courtDelays introducing system by Spanish IT multinational Indra Sistemas leaves train operator holding €50m write-down
Read more »
Katie Cantwell's Culinary Journey: From Family Dinners to Restaurant InnovationKatie Cantwell reflects on the importance of food and hospitality in her life. She advocates for greater recognition of the hospitality industry as a long-term career and the need for fair wages. Cantwell also praises the collaborative spirit of her restaurant team and the joys of shared dining experiences.
Read more »
Katie Taylor Retires With a Triumph at Croke ParkKatie Taylor ended her illustrious boxing career with a decisive victory over Flora Pili at Croke Park. The event, attended by 80,000 fans, celebrated Taylor's legacy with a spectacular show, affirming her status as one of the sport's greatest figures.
Read more »