Rape shield law 'not doing the job' and should be repealed, report finds

News News

Rape shield law 'not doing the job' and should be repealed, report finds
Rape Shield, Sexual Offence Trial, Complainant Protection

A new report by Professor Sinéad Ring and Rape Crisis Ireland reveals that the Irish rape shield law is failing to protect complainants from irrelevant sexual history questions, with 39% of trials involving evidence admission applications. The report argues the law should be repealed due to its ineffective protection against character attacks and outdated assumptions.

A report by Maynooth University associate law professor Sinéad Ring, supported by Rape Crisis Ireland (RCI), has found that Ireland's ' rape shield' law is 'not doing the job it was designed to do' and should be repealed.

The law, intended to protect rape complainants from being questioned about their sexual history during trial, is being undermined by the current discretion judges hold in granting evidence admission applications. The report indicates that 39% of sexual offence trials last year involved such applications, with significant numbers involving young complainants, suggesting the law fails to adequately protect survivors from intrusive cross-examination based on outdated stereotypes.

We have summarized this news so that you can read it quickly. If you are interested in the news, you can read the full text here. Read more:

IrishTimes /  🏆 3. in İE

Rape Shield Sexual Offence Trial Complainant Protection Evidence Admission Rape Crisis Ireland

 

Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines

Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.

Oura Postpones Nasdaq IPO Citing Uncertain Market ConditionsOura Postpones Nasdaq IPO Citing Uncertain Market ConditionsOura has postponed its planned Nasdaq IPO despite strong demand, citing uncertainty in the IPO market. The Finnish-American smart ring maker had hoped to raise up to $2.2 billion.
Read more »

Sinéad O'Sullivan: What one Kerry road tells us about road safetySinéad O'Sullivan: What one Kerry road tells us about road safetyAn impromptu civilian road safety investigation unit emerged in Kerry, where residents counted collisions, measured footpaths and cross-referenced design standards
Read more »

Drill Down on Young Men's Attitudes Toward Rape in IrelandDrill Down on Young Men's Attitudes Toward Rape in IrelandA survey from the Dublin Rape Crisis Centre reveals that two‑in‑five men under 25 blame rape victims who were drinking or drugged, while only 15 of all adults hold this view. The research also shows widespread disbelief in rape claims, fear of not being believed as a major barrier to seeking help, and a lack of faith in Ireland's justice system. Surprising gender and age‑based differences highlight an urgent need for targeted education and support programs.
Read more »

Cornell Gang Rape Case: Text Messages Revealed as NY Reopens InvestigationCornell Gang Rape Case: Text Messages Revealed as NY Reopens InvestigationNew York prosecutors have reopened a criminal investigation into an alleged gang rape at a Cornell University fraternity, following the publication of text messages between the accuser and a male defendant that suggest confusion and regret about the incident. The case involves seven students accused of assaulting a female student in October 2024, with previous internal university punishments drawing public outrage.
Read more »