+34
It’s easy to rage against the machine. It’s harder to propose a viable alternative
Mark Little's new book, The Last Good Day on the Internet, published next week, argues that we are entering an “age of intention” in which ordinary people reclaim agency on social media.
Photograph: Nick Bradshaw / The Irish Timesera the word carried a faint whiff of the compound and the commune, of Charles Manson or Jim Jones. To follow, in ordinary English, is to trail behind someone, to defer, to obey. But an entire communications economy got built on the cheerful assumption that amassing followers was a wholesome ambition, a sign that you had something worth saying.
As the platforms grew in reach and scale, the follower count became shorthand for status and proof of influence. To this day you will see it deployed as evidence of raw power. A politician commands millions of followers, a pop star tens of millions, the figures presented as evidence of who matters most. Despite all this, analysts have been predicting the end of the follower for years.
The trends they describe are hardly new. Social media platforms that began as chronological timelines, orderly streams of posts from accounts you had subscribed to, have been steadily downgraded or replaced.started weighting feeds by predicted engagement rather than recency more than a decade ago, with Instagram abandoning the purely chronological feed as far back as 2016.arrived and dispensed with the premise almost entirely, building its whole experience around a For You page that served up strangers rather than friends.leaned hard into recommendation.
One by one, the networks quietly demoted the people you had followed in favour of whatever their ranking systems judged would keep you scrolling. It has taken a surprisingly long time for the implications to be fully grasped. It was Patreon co-founder Jack Conte who coined the phrase “the death of the follower” in a widely shared keynote at the South by Southwest festival in 2024.
Conte argued that a follow no longer guaranteed you would reach the person who made it, and that creators should cultivate genuine supporters rather than chase vanity metrics. Others took up the theme. At the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, researchers set out how these ranking systems actually work, while admitting that the wider research community is unable to observe or explain the feedback loops of human behaviour they set in motion.
The machines that now shape public attention gave rise to a cascade of social and psychological effects that are only imperfectly understood. It is fair to say that these developments have not been universally welcomed, including among those who built their business models on the back of the old rules. The marketing industry spent 15 years persuading clients that followers were the goal.
A recent trend report from US agency MDRN Logic, also titled The Death of the Follower , counsels brands to stop hoarding followers and instead earn attention afresh with every post, cultivating a recognisable voice rather than mere volume and behaving more like a personality with a point of view. Some of may feel the last thing the world needs is more brands with a point of view, but that’s a subject for another day.
More broadly, the uneasy sense that we have lost control of our own feeds is curdling into a more existential sense of dread. That was visible in the debate following last month’s crash on the M9, in which, seriously injuring the four occupants of a car travelling in the correct direction.
A grim consensus quickly formed, running from gardaí to child psychologists, that recommendation engines designed to amplify whatever provokes the strongest reaction helped feed a culture of recklessness performed for an audience. The question of who is being served this material, and why, is belatedly being asked. Some are trying to fight back. The steady drift of X/Twitter to the right since Elon Musk’s acquisition drove waves of refugees to the alternatives.
Mastodon offers no algorithm at all, only the accounts you choose in the order they posted. Bluesky lets users select or build their own feeds, a deliberate rebuke to the opaque engagement machines of the incumbents. The pitch, in each case, is a return of agency to the person doing the scrolling.
But it is far from clear that either platform is achieving critical mass, and Bluesky in particular has been criticised for creating a monoculture where ideological conformity is rigidly enforced. It’s easy to rage against the machine. It’s harder to propose a viable alternative. But there are advocates and activists who believe that agency can and should be returned to the individual human user.
The most recent case for a more optimistic vision comes from Mark Little, the former RTÉ correspondent and founder of Storyful, whose new book, The Last Good Day on the Internet, published next week, argues that we are entering an “age of intention” in which ordinary people reclaim agency. Little acknowledges that recommendation systems have been silently mining our subconscious desires for more than a decade, but retains a belief in the more open and egalitarian principles that animated much of the early years of the internet can be revived.
I would love to share his hope but I fear it is misplaced. These decentralised havens and digital commons remain minnows beside the tech giants, and the oligarchs who run them have not the slightest intention of surrendering their power without a fight. X faces Irish investigation over concerns children not protected from pornography and violenceIs that David Beckham in The Gentlemen?
‘I was given three months to live without treatment, six-to-eight months with treatment’ Flood map: See the Irish coastline areas at ‘very high’ risk from flooding, erosion or sea level rise ‘I am now over €300 out of pocket in extra storage costs’: A reader’s ordeal after ordering Homebase shedPublican says he can’t pay cleaner after losing nearly €200,000 in four months running barIrish Open at Doonbeg: What are the tee times? When is it on TV?
When is Donald Trump going to be there? A bespoke collection of Irish Times journalism exclusively for subscribers featuring previews and the best of the week that was
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News: You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Rise in number of children living below poverty lineEconomic and Social Research Institute finds levels of child poverty higher when housing costs factored in
Read more »
The ESRI said the number of children in households below the poverty line grew by almost a fifth in 2024.The Economic and Social Research Institute (ESRI) has reported a significant increase in child poverty, with the number of children living in households below the poverty line rising by nearly 20% in 2024. This sharp rise highlights the growing economic challenges faced by families, particularly in the context of rising living costs and stagnant wages. The ESRI, known for its expert analysis of economic and social trends in Ireland, has likely identified key factors contributing to this alarming trend, such as inflation, housing costs, and changes in social welfare policies.
Read more »
Trump's Truth Social post claims USA covers North America and IcelandA map posted by Donald Trump on social media shows the American flag covering North America, Central America, the Caribbean, Greenland, and Iceland, with the entire region labeled as the 'United States of America.' The Icelandic Foreign Minister has summoned the US ambassador regarding this post.
Read more »
Yoga Teacher Finds Purpose and Community After Cancer DiagnosisAfter receiving a cancer diagnosis, Irish yoga instructor Naoise Ní Bhrion turned to social media and the Irish language to rebuild her life, inspire others, and maintain a strong online community.
Read more »