A Dublin man has been ordered to pay €40,000 in damages to a plumbing firm after posting defamatory online reviews on Trustpilot and Google Maps. The court found that the reviews, which included untrue references to the firm as 'con men' and 'gangsters', were damaging to the company's reputation.
A man who posted defamatory internet reviews about a plumbing firm has been ordered to pay €40,000 to the company by the High Court. James Manning, of Castleside Drive, Rathfarnham, Dublin, was found to have defamed Stillorgan Gas Heating and Plumbing Ltd, Dún Laoghaire, Dublin, in four reviews he posted in February 2022 on the Trustpilot review website and the firm’s Google maps review page.
Two of the reviews, which included untrue references to the firm such as “con men”, were removed after 24 hours, and two were removed after four days. Mr Manning failed to put in a defence to the company’s action, and last October the High Court gave judgment in default of an appearance by the defendant. The case then came before Mr Justice Conleth Bradley to assess damages and he found, in a judgment published this week, that the company was entitled to €40,000 in damages over the defamation. Mr Justice Bradley said the reviews were put up shortly after work was carried out by the plumbing company on the gas boiler in a rented property in Ranelagh owned by Mr Manning’s sister. Mr Manning assisted in the management of the property. The boiler was found to be working, but a problem arose in relation to the circulating water pump and it had to be replaced, and other work had to be carried out. As a result of his refusal to pay, the company removed the pump, pump valves, piping and compression fittings they had installed. He then posted what he said were four reviews describing the firm as “absolute con men”, “gangsters” and “cowboys”. He also told the firm he would be making a report to Rathmines gardaí, which he did on February 4th, 2022. Mr Justice Bradley said he took into account three shorter reviews and the last, longer review on Trustpilot, which Mr Manning submitted following contact from the company’s solicitor in relation to the three earlier reviews. In the longer review he referred to the firm as “rogue traders”. The company owner, Dara Keogh, told the court he considered this destructive of his firm’s reputation.Mr Manning appeared at the assessment of damages hearing and said that when his posted review was taken down, he should not have replaced it with the post in his wife’s name.He said Mr Manning, at the hearing, expressed regret at the tone of his review. Having regard to guidelines laid down by the Supreme Court, he considered it to be in the moderate category of seriousness of defamation, and the company was therefore entitled to an award of €40,000. On Wednesday, the case returned before Mr Justice Bradley to deal with the question of costs, but there was no appearance for Mr Manning
DEFAMATION ONLINE REVIEWS TRUSTPILOT GOOGLE MAPS HIGH COURT DAMAGES
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Psychiatric Report Ordered for Man Accused of Stabbings in DublinA 29-year-old Brazilian national, Gabrial Fereira Motta Valladares, has been charged with four offences related to stabbings in Dublin's Stoneybatter area. He appeared at Cloverhill District Court, where a judge ordered a psychiatric report after the accused made no application for bail and declined to answer most of the charges.
Read more »
Another man, 30s, arrested in connection with death of man in BraySix males previously arrested in connection with the death of William Moorehouse have all been released without charge
Read more »
Man due in court after alleged pub car park assault leaves man fighting for lifeThe suspect is due to appear at Blanchardstown District Court following an alleged assault in the car park of the Clonsilla Inn that left a man in critical condition
Read more »
Watch new Bohs man score in Premier League against Man Utd, Arsenal and EvertonLys Mousset played Premier League football for Bournemouth and Sheffield United, and scored against some high-profile opposition.
Read more »
Man (20s) arrested following fatal assault of man (60s) in Malahide, Co DublinGardaí attended house in Gainsborough Lawn where man was found unresponsive
Read more »
Gardaí continuing to question man (20s) arrested following fatal assault of man (60s) in MalahideGardaí attended house in Gainsborough Lawn on Saturday morning where man was found unresponsive
Read more »