Breda O'Brien's article highlights the issues facing science teachers and students in the new Senior Cycle sciences syllabus design. The draft specifications for biology, chemistry, and physics are inadequate and lack clarity on what needs to be taught and learned.
Sir, – Breda O’Brien’s excellent article on the proposed “ learning outcomes only” model of syllabus design in the new Senior Cycle sciences brilliantly highlights the issues facing science teachers and their students .
Teachers, and their students, deserve absolute clarity on what needs to be taught and learned, and to what depth, and the recently published draft specifications for Senior Cycle biology, chemistry and physics are grossly inadequate in this regard. The sole use vague learning outcomes to outline the subject content will result in confusion, inconsistency and unfairness. It’s the equivalent of asking a builder to construct a house with just a rough sketch without any detailed plans or designs.
One doesn’t need to search too hard for recent evidence of problems caused by vague and poorly constructed syllabuses; the Junior Cycle science specification used a similar flawed design and fails to provide an adequate platform for further study in the sciences. Similarly, a new specification for agricultural science was introduced five years ago using the same model and this has caused mass frustration among teachers of that subject.
The allocation of 40 per cent for an additional assessment component in the Senior Cycle sciences is also proposed. The proposal means students in biology, chemistry and physics would carry out an extensive laboratory or field-based experiment and write a report on it. The reality is that students don’t have equal access to school laboratories and the equipment levels vary enormously from school to school.
Our teachers and students deserve the best possible subject specifications, based on international best practice within a high-stakes environment. Comparing what the NCCA has produced with established curriculums in the UK or within the International Baccalaureate is like comparing chalk and cheese. We must do better and the reputation of Ireland’s Senior Cycle is genuinely in jeopardy.
Learning Outcomes Syllabus Design Senior Cycle Sciences Biology Chemistry Physics Teachers Students
Ireland Latest News, Ireland Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Digital exam papers extended to Junior Cycle studentsThe State Examinations Commission has extended to Junior Cycle students a measure which makes it easier for some visually impaired candidates to sit State exams.
Read more »
Rollout of free schoolbooks for Junior Cycle students ‘in doubt’More than 80 per cent of principals say necessary supports to navigate procurement process not in place
Read more »
How to quit the cycle of feeling bad from social mediaWhen you think of all those things that stop you from moving forward, how far down your list do you go before you find social media?
Read more »
Gardaí to spend €250,000 on new mountain bikes for cycle patrolsUp to 200 bicycles will be added to the fleet, which includes 50 mountain bikes and eight e-bikes that were purchased last year
Read more »
Cycle Track: How To Understand Your Period And Help Alleviate Pain, According To An ExpertCycle tracking, diet and supplements can help with period pain, says expert Lisa de Jong, who shares everything you need to know
Read more »
Gerry Thornley: Proposed changes confronting World Rugby could have transformative impactConstant revisions of and amendments to the game’s laws are product of coaches finding ways to bend them to their advantage
Read more »